Presenting a Sustainability Reporting Model for Municipalities

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. Candidate in Accounting, Kish International Campus, University of Tehran, Kish, Iran.

2 Professor of Accounting, Faculty of Social Sciences and Economics, Alzahra University, Tehran, Iran.

3 Professor of Accounting, Faculty of Management, School of Accounting and Finance, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.

10.22103/jak.2023.20373.3786

Abstract

Objective: The occurrence of a large number of scandals and financial corruption in some Iranian city councils and municipalities in the last decade shows evidence of unethical and irresponsible practices from the economic, social, and environmental dimensions. Also, the development process of cities and the consequent increase in municipal revenues, on the one hand, and the lack of proper supervision on the performance of municipalities due to the existence of the city council, on the other hand, have increased the power and authority of municipalities. Thus, municipalities face increasing pressure from citizens to have a broad attitude regarding their goals and activities in economic, social, and environmental dimensions. Sustainability reporting is one of the main drivers of change in the company's sustainability activities. Preparing a sustainability report can influence change in public sector organizations. Regarding the advantages of sustainability reporting in the various companies, including public and governmental organizations, to preserve the social rights of citizens, environmental resources, and the economic benefits of shareholders, the primary purpose of this research is to understand the current situation of sustainability reporting in municipalities, explaining its dimensions and indicators, and finally presenting a sustainability reporting model for municipalities.
 Method: The current research consists of three steps: 1. Identifying sustainability concepts and keywords in the literature using content analysis techniques; 2. Identifying the primary indicators of the topics discussed in the focus group using the coding method, 3. Using the method Delphi (which is conducted to validate the dimensions and indicators identified in the second stage), and 4. Finally, it will present the final sustainability reporting model for Iranian municipalities. In the first step, keywords that are used for sustainability reporting using the method of content analysis of sustainability reports of different cities (such as Sydney, Toronto, KF, Florida, and Dubai) and guidelines related to the field of sustainability (such as ESG, GRI, IFC, ISO26000, SASB, and CDP) were extracted. The necessary information was collected through the focus group in the second step, and the topics were discussed. The participants were selected from a group of experts from the Iranian municipalities (financial and economic, urban services, and green spaces). These people had the necessary knowledge, experience, expertise, scientific and professional sincerity in different ways and based on specific research. After identifying dimensions and indicators, we prepared and set up a questionnaire in the third step and distributed it to the experts from municipalities and other stakeholders. The Delphi method was used to create consensus and to screen sustainability categories. Finally, a proposed model of sustainability reporting for Iranian municipalities was presented.
Results: The findings show that the dimensions of sustainability reporting in municipalities include "economic", "environmental", "work and production", "management and human capital", "determinants of excellence and progress", and "reporting characteristics". Also, four indicators of economic performance, the economic conditions of the stakeholders, the municipalities' economic conditions, and the country's macroeconomic conditions are related to the economic dimension. Four indicators, including compatibility with the environment, environmental sustainability, infrastructure and facilities, and the allocation of facilities and privileges, are related to the environmental dimension. Six indicators, including sustainable supply chain, legal requirements, sustainable intellectual interaction (human capital), adherence to legal payments, use of technology, and corporate governance, belong to the work and production dimension. Six indicators of effective communication, ethical characteristics of accountants, the relationship between employee and manager, management ability, expert managers, and expert forces belong to the management and human capital dimension. Four indicators of participation and development of valuation methods, dealing without discrimination with offenders, criteria for determining rights and benefits, and responsibility and social involvement belong to the dimension of determinants of excellence and progress. Seven indicators, including accounting records, timeliness of report, compliance with accounting principles, neutrality of the report, report transparency, sources of collecting the report, and qualitative characteristics of the information, are the report's characteristics dimension.
Conclusion: Sustainability reporting can be considered as a solution for making changes in the organizational management of municipalities, transparency in all municipal matters such as financial (economic), urban services and green space (environmental), social responsibility, and reacting to the requirements of all stakeholders. Exploring the sustainability reports of various cities in the world showed that they have no limitations on how to present and use the dimensions and indicators included in the current guidelines and standards, such as GRI, CDP, and SASB, to prepare the sustainability report. They do not follow a specified routine. In other words, in order to legitimize themselves, in line with accountability, these organizations voluntarily disclose sustainability reports. The results of this research can be utilized as a practical step to create the necessary understanding and motivation for sustainability reporting and to attract the managers' and regulators' attention to incorporate sustainability reporting in their voluntary or mandatory reporting to stakeholders with a sustainable development perspective.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

بابائی، فاطمه؛ رحمانی، علی؛ همایون، سعید و امین، وحید (1400). رابطه بین عملکرد پایداری شرکتی و ارزش شرکت: با تأکید بر نقش امتیاز افشا و اندازه شرکت. مجله دانش حسابداری، 12(3)، 27-1. https://jak.uk.ac.ir/article_2908_ 1db6f63f237d7404168642717791dfee.pdf.
برزگر، قدرت‌اله (۱۳۹۲). مدلی برای افشای مسئولیت اجتماعی شرکت‌ها (CSR) و ارتباط آن با عملکرد مالی. رساله دکتری حسابداری. دانشگاه علامه طباطبائی.
چناری بوکت، حسن و بنی‌مهد، بهمن (۱۳۹۸). پایداری شرکتی: راهبردی تئوریکی و یکپارچه با رویکرد دستوری و عملگرا. نشریه علمی حسابداری مدیریت، 12(42)، 125-103. https://jma.srbiau.ac.ir/article_14416_74d22a142ace4d4792e45eeb32265203.pdf.
خاکی، غلامرضا (۱۳۹۱). روش تحقیق با رویکرد پایان نامه نویسی (چاپ سوم). تهران، انتشارات فوژان.
دانایی‌فرد، حسن؛ الوانی، سیدمهدی و آذر، عادل (1392). روش‌شناسی پژوهش کمی در مدیریت: رویکردی جامع (چاپ نهم). تهران، انتشارات صفار.
عبدی، مصطفی؛ کردستانی، غلامرضا و رضازاده، جواد (۱۳۹۸). طـراحی الگوی منسجم گزارشگری پایداری شرکت‌ها. پژوهش‌های حسابداری مالی، 11(4)، 44-23. https://far.ui.ac.ir/article_24305_ed2746051418ce5ed3fb700401b849c1.pdf.
ماپار، مهسا؛ جعفری، محمدجواد؛ منصوری، نبی‌اله؛ ارجمندی، رضا و عزیزی‌نژاد، رضا (۱۳۹۷). طراحی سیستم ارزیابی و گزارش‌دهی ‌عملکرد پایدار شهرداری کلان شهرها، مطالعه موردی: عملکرد سلامت شهرداری تهران. فصلنامه بهداشت و ایمنی کار، 8(1)، 80-65. http://jhsw.tums.ac.ir/article-1-5808-fa.html.
معصومی، سید رسول؛ صالح نژاد، سید حسن و ذبیحی زرین کلایی، علی (۱۳۹۷). شناسایی متغیرهای مؤثر بر میزان گزارشگری پایداری شرکت‌های پذیرفته شده در بورس اوراق بهادار تهران. مجله دانش حسابرسی، 18(70)، 221-195. https://qjma.atu.ac.ir/article_11092_ 26c59277406338e85a50b7faee7a683a.pdf.
ملکیان، اسفندیار؛ فخاری، حسین و جفایی رهنی، منیر (۱۳۹۸). بررسی تأثیر ویژگی‌های هیئت مدیره شرکت بر میزان گزارشگری زیست‌محیطی، اجتماعی و راهبری شرکتی. مجله دانش حسابداری، 10(2)، 112-77. https://jak.uk.ac.ir/article_2274_ 517ea6c58ef2e786d42200ed39fcee76.pdf.
References
Abdi, M., Kurdestani, Gh., & Rezazadeh, J. (2018). Designing of Corporates’ Coherent Sustainability Reporting Model. Journal of Financial Accounting Research, 11(4), 23-44 https://far.ui.ac.ir/article_24305_ed2746051418ce5ed3fb700401b849c1.pdf [In Persian].
Alcaraz-Quiles, F.J., Navarro-Galera, A., & Ortiz-Rodrıguez, D. (2014). A comparative analysis of transparency in sustainability reporting by local and regional governments, Lex Localis. Journal of Self-Government, 12(1), 55-79 https://doi.org/10.4335/12.1.55-78(2014).
Babaei, F., Rahmani, A., Homayoun, S., & Amin, V. (2021). The relationship between corporate sustainability performance and firm value: Emphasizing the role of disclosure score and firm size. Journal of Accounting Knowledge, 12(3), 1-27 https://jak.uk.ac.ir/article_2908_ 1db6f63f237d7404168642717791dfee.pdf [In Persian].
Ball, A. (2002). Sustainability accounting in UK local government an agenda for research. ACCA Research Report, Association of Chartered Certified Accountants, London, No. 78.
Ball, A. (2004). A sustainability accounting project for the UK local government sector? Testing the social theory mapping process and locating a frame of reference. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 15(8), 1009-1035 https://doi.org/10.1016/S1045-2354(02)00209-5.
Ball, A. (2005). Environmental accounting and change in UK local government. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, 18(3), 346-373 https://doi.org/10.1108/09513570510600738.
Ball, A. (2007). Environmental accounting as workplace activism. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 18(7), 759-778 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpa.2006.04.005.
Ball, A., & Grubnic, S., (2007). Sustainability acounting and accountability in the public sector, in Unerman, J., Bebbington, J. and O’Dwyer, B. (Eds), Sustainability Accounting and Accountability, Routledge, London, 243-265.
Ball, A., Grubnic, S., & Birchall, J. (2014). Sustainability accounting and accountability in the public sector, in Beggington, J., Unerman, J. and O’Dwyer, B. (Eds), Sustainability Accounting and Accountability, Routledge, London, 176-196.
Barzegar, Gh. (2014). A model for disclosing Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) and its relation to financial performance. Dissertation Thesis, Allameh Tabatabaei University [In Persian].
Bellini, O., Rodrigues, N., Lagioia, T., & Freitas, T. (2019). Public Sector (UN) Sustainability: a study of GRI adherence and sustainability reporting disclosure standards in Public Institutions and State-Owned Companies of the Public Agency Sector. Cuadernos de Contabilidad, 20(49), 1-28 DOI:10.11144/ Javeriana.cc20-49.psss.
Brockett, A., & Rezaee, Z., (2012). Corporate Sustainability: Integrating Performance and Reporting Hoboken. NJ: John Wiley and Sons.
Chenari Bouket, H., & BaniMahd, B., (2019). Corporate Sustainability: Theorical and Integrated Strategic Imperative and Pragmatic Approach. Journal of Management accounting, 12(42), 103-125 https://jma.srbiau.ac.ir/article_14416_74d22a142ace4d4792e45eeb32265203.pdf [In Persian].
Costa, B. & Lima Crisóstomo, V., (2017). Comprehensiveness of Corporate Social Responsibility Report of Brazilian Companies: An analysis of its evolution and determinants. Cuadernos de Contabilidad, 18(45), 125-151 DOI:10.3390/risks10050103.
Cruz, C., Marques, A. & Ferreira, A. (2009). Informações ambientais na contabilidade pública: reconhecimento de sua importância para a sustentabilidade. Sociedade, contabilidade e Gestão, 4(2), DOI:10.21446/scg_ufrj.v4i2.13176.
Danaei Fard, H., Alvani, S M., & Azar, A. (2012). Quantitative research methodology in management: a comprehensive approach (ninth edition). Tehran, Safar Publications [In Persian].
Dik, R. (2017). Sustainability in local governments: Disclosures in Dutch and Canadian municipal annual reports. Master’s Thesis, Radboud University. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/1725/ e2392150fc00a532d98800d3cdec4f20b2cb.pdf.
Domingues, A.R., Lozano, R., Ceulemans, K., & Ramos, T.B. (2017). Sustainability reporting in public sector organisations: Exploring the relation between the reporting process and organisational change management for sustainability. Journal of Environmental Management. 192, 292-301.
Farneti, F., & Guthrie, J. (2009). Sustainability reporting by Australian public sector organizations: why they report. Accounting Forum, 33(2), 89-98.
Gazzola, P., Amelio, S., Papagiannis, F., & Michaelides, Z. (2019). Sustainability reporting practices and their social impact to NGO funding in Italy. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Available online 30 April 2019, 102085.
Gibson, R., & Guthrie, J. (1995). Recent environmental disclosures in annual reports of Australian public and private sector organisations, Accounting Forum, (19) 2/3, 111-127.
Global Reporting Initiative (GRI)., (2018). Sustainability Disclosure Database. Data Legend. Amsterdam: Global Reporting Initiative.
Gonzalez-García, S., Rama, M., Cortes, A., García-Guaita, F., Nunez, A., Gonzalez Louro, L., Teresa Moreira, M., & Feijoo, G. (2019). Embedding environmental, economic and social indicators in the evaluation of the sustainability of the municipalities of Galicia (northwest of Spain). Journal of Cleaner Production, 234, 27-42.
Goswami, K., & Lodhia, S. (2014). Sustainability disclosure patterns of South Australian local councils: a case study. Public Money and Management, 34(4), 273-280.
Greco, G., Sciulli, N., & D’Onza, G. (2013). The influence of stakeholder engagement on sustainability reporting: evidence from Italian local councils. Public Management Review, 17(4),1-24.
GRI. (2004). Public Agency sustainability reporting: a gri resource document in support of the publlic agency sector supplemen. Global Reporting Initiative, Amsterdam.
GRI. (2005). Sector supplement for public agencies. Global Reporting Initiative, Amsterdam.
GRI FPA. (2012). integrating sustainability into reporting – an australian public sector perspective. GRI Focal Point Australia (FPA), Sydney.
Guthrie, J., & Farneti, F. (2008). GRI sustainability reporting by Australian public sector organizations. Public Money and Management, 28(6), 361-366.
Hopwood, B., Mellor, M., & O’Brien, G. (2005). Sustainable development: mapping different approaches, Sustainable Development, 13(1), 38-52.
Hoque, Z., & Adams, C. (2008). Measuring public sector performance: A study of government departments in Australia, CPA Australia, Melbourne.
Kaur, A., & Lodhia, S. (2014). The state of disclosures on stakeholder engagement in sustainability reporting in Australian local councils. Pacific Accounting Review, 26(1/2), 54-74.
Kaur, A., & Lodhia, S. (2016). Influences on stakeholder engagement in sustainability accounting and reporting: a study of Australian local councils. Corporate Responsibility and Stakeholding, Emerald Group Publishing, Bingley, 105-129.
Kaur, A., & Lodhia, S. (2017). The extent of stakeholder engagement in sustainability accounting and reporting: does empowerment of stakeholders really exist? Modern Organisational Governance, Emerald Publishing, Bingley, 129-145.
Kaur, A., & Lodhia, S. (2018). Stakeholder engagement in sustainability accounting and reporting: a study of Australian local councils. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, 31(1), 338-368.
Kaur, A., & Lodhia, S. (2019). Key issues and challenges in stakeholder engagement in sustainability reporting: a study of Australian local councils. Pacific Accounting Review, 31(1), 2-18.
Khaki, Gh. (2011). Research method with thesis writing approach (third edition). Tehran, Fujan Publications [In Persian].
Leeson, R., Ivers, J., & Dickinson, D. (2005). Sustainability reporting by the public sector: momentum changes in the practice, uptake and form of reporting by public agencies. Accountability Forum, 8(12/21).
Lodhia, S., & Jacobs, K. (2013). The practice turn in environmental reporting: a study into current practices in two Australian commonwealth department. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, 26(4), 595-615.
Lodhia, S., Jacobs, K., & Park, Y.J. (2012). Driving public sector environmental reporting: the disclosure practices of Australian commonwealth departments. Public Management Review. 14(5), 631-647.
Macintosh, A., & Wilkinson, D. (2012). Are we progressing? Comprehensive monitoring and reporting in Australia. The Australian Collaboration.
Malekian, E., Fakhari, H., & Jafaei Rahani, M. (2018). Impact of board of directors' characteristics on environmental, social, and corporate governance reporting. Journal of Accounting Knowledge, 10(2), 77-112 https://jak.uk.ac.ir/article_2274_517ea6c58ef2e786d42200ed39fcee76.pdf [In Persian].
Mapar, M., Jafari, M J., Mansouri, N., Arjmandi, R., & Azizinejad, R. (2018). Developing assessment and reporting system for sustainability performance in municipalities of megacities Case Study: Health performance of Tehran municipality. Journal of Health and Safety at Work, 8(1), 65-80 http://jhsw.tums.ac.ir/article-1-5808-fa.html [In Persian].
Marcuccio, M., & Steccolini, I. (2005). Social and environmental reporting in local authorities: a new Italian fashion? Public Management Review, 7(2), 155-176.
Masoumi, S.R., Saleh Nejad, S.H., & Zabihi Zarin Kolaei, A. (2017). Identifying the effective variables on the level of sustainability reporting of companies listed in the Tehran Stock Exchange. Journal of Audit Science, 18(70), 195-221 https://qjma.atu.ac.ir/article_11092_26c59277406338e85a50b7faee7a683a. pdf [In Persian].
Mussari, R., & Monfardini, P. (2010). Practices of social reporting in public sector and nonprofit organizations: an Italian perspective. Public Management Review, 12(4), 487-492.
Niemann, L., & Hoppe, T. (2018). Sustainability reporting by local governments: a magic tool? Lessons on use and usefulness from European pioneers. Public Management Review, 20(1), 201-223.
Orazalin, N., & Mahmood, M. (2018). Economic, environmental, and social performance indicators of sustainability reporting: Evidence from the Russian oil and gas industry. Energy Policy, 121, 70–79.
Qian, W., Burritt, R., & Monroe, G., (2011). Environmental management accounting in local government: A case of waste management. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, 24(1), 93-128.
Rezaee, Z. (2015). Business sustainability: performance, compliance, accountability and integrat reporting. Sheffield, UK: Greenleaf Publishing Limited.
Sulkowski, A. (2016). City sustainability reporting: An emerging & desirable legal necessity. Pace Enviromental Law Review, 33, 278-299.
Tavares, C. (2018). Analysis of GRI sustainability reports issued by portuguese public sector entities. Digital Communication Management. DOI: 10.5772/intechopen.76221.
Tetrevova, L., & Jelinkova, M. (2019). Municipal social responsibility of statutory cities in the Czech Republic. Sustainability, 11(8), 1-19.
Tonello, M., & Singer, T. (2015). Sustainability Practices. The Conference Board, https://www. conferenceboard .org/ pdfdownload.cfm?masterProductID=9311.
Williams, B., Wilmshurst, T., & Clift, R. (2011). Sustainability reporting by local government in Australia current and future prospects. Accounting Forum, 35(3), 176-186.
Williams, B.R. (2015). Reporting on sustainability by Australian councils–a communication Perspective. Asian Review of Accounting, 23(2), 186-203.

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 15 October 2022
  • Revise Date: 30 January 2023
  • Accept Date: 01 February 2023

Share

How to cite

Statistics